Mountain Life
  • Daily Content
    • Trips & Expeditions
    • Climbing
    • Mountain Biking
    • Mountain Lifer
    • Multiplicity
    • On The Trail
    • Paddling
    • Photography
    • Skiing
    • Snowboarding
    • Stay & Play
    • Surfing
    • The Great Outdoors
    • The ML Interview
    • Travel
  • GEAR
  • VIDEOS
  • STORE
  • Magazines
    • ML Coast Mountains
    • ML Rocky Mountains
    • Vie En Montagne
    • ML Blue Mountains
    • ML Annual
    • ML Subscriptions
  • ABOUT
    • What is ML?
    • Our Team
    • Newsletter
    • Adventure Grant
    • Distribution
  • Podcast
  • Contests
  • CONTACT
    • ML Agency
    • Advertising
    • Contribute
Subscription Form

Get notified of the best News

Social Links
Instagram 22K Followers
Facebook 0 Likes
Twitter 0 Followers
Pinterest 1K Followers
Vimeo 34 Followers
LinkedIn 0
22K Followers
0 Likes
0 Followers
1K Followers
Mountain Life
Mountain Life
  • Daily Content
    • Trips & Expeditions
    • Climbing
    • Mountain Biking
    • Mountain Lifer
    • Multiplicity
    • On The Trail
    • Paddling
    • Photography
    • Skiing
    • Snowboarding
    • Stay & Play
    • Surfing
    • The Great Outdoors
    • The ML Interview
    • Travel
  • GEAR
  • VIDEOS
  • STORE
  • Magazines
    • ML Coast Mountains
    • ML Rocky Mountains
    • Vie En Montagne
    • ML Blue Mountains
    • ML Annual
    • ML Subscriptions
  • ABOUT
    • What is ML?
    • Our Team
    • Newsletter
    • Adventure Grant
    • Distribution
  • Podcast
  • Contests
  • CONTACT
    • ML Agency
    • Advertising
    • Contribute
  • CLIMBING
  • Rockies

Facing Uncertainty: The Role of Chance in Mountain Adventures

  • March 13, 2023
  • Mountain Life Media
Total
0
Shares
0
0
0
0
0
0
Total
0
Shares
Share 0
Tweet 0
Pin it 0
Share 0
Share 0
Share 0

ACMG/IFMGA Mountain Guide and Parks Canada Visitor Safety Specialist Steve Holeczi discusses the role of chance in mountain adventures and how to assess the unknown.

Uncertainty (ˈən-ˈsər-tᵊn-tē – noun): the state of being uncertain; doubt; hesitancy.

Uncertainty stems from not having enough information to reliably estimate an event’s likelihood or potential outcomes. This is true in all aspects of life, including decision-making in the mountains.

Every person deals with uncertainty and the feelings it creates in their daily lives. Which job to take? High- or low-risk investments? Or more recently, how to navigate COVID? When people make decisions under uncertainty, they may not know if they made a good choice until much later—if at all. Humans naturally want answers, even when answers may not be available.

Mitchell Leong snowdrift
Facing uncertainty. Ice cave on the Icefields Parkway. cover photo of the winter ’23 issue of ML Rocky Mountains. PHOTO: MITCHELL LEONG

Decisions in the mountains are no different. The night before certain alpine climbs or ski descents I often grappled with uncertainty, lying awake wondering whether chance would be on our side if my partners and I took the risk. The level of doubt this caused mainly depended on the hazards—potential sources of harm—to which we were considering exposing ourselves.

All mountain hazards have varying levels of uncertainty. For example, on the extreme end, a serac is entirely uncertain. We have no idea when or if it will collapse, but we know the worst outcomes would be severe. It may be a small chance that the serac collapses in the short time you are exposed, but do you accept that risk knowing what would happen? We may know more about other hazards such as near-surface avalanche problems or muddy trails. With hazards that have less uncertainty, chance may play a role in the outcomes, but much of the risk can be reduced with skill and experience. Knowing which hazards have more, or less, uncertainty is important, but it takes time to assess.

The night before certain alpine climbs or ski descents I often grappled with uncertainty, lying awake wondering whether chance would be on our side if my partners and I took the risk.


Related Article:

ML Rocky Mountains Winter ’22-’23 Issue Out Now

It also takes time to get a sense of how comfortable you are with uncertainty and what chances you are willing to take. Personally, there have been times when I wanted to take risks in highly-uncertain mountain environments. Skill was a part of risk management (waiting for conditions, moving fast), but I chose to go knowing chance played the most significant role between survival and catastrophe. I craved that experience because I reconciled that the reward was worth the risk. Other times it felt like the reward wasn’t worth it and I didn’t go. My risk tolerance has changed over time, and now I prefer trips with fewer sources of uncertainty where I can mainly manage the risks with skill.

The mountains can be daunting, but having a process for decision-making can help us produce better choices over time and result in less intimidating decisions in the future. Here are some factors to consider before heading on your next adventure.

12 PolarCircus 1
Speaking of uncertainty… Adam Bidwell on one of the upper ice pitches of the iconic Polar Circus (WI5) on the Icefields Parkway. Story here. Photo: Peter Hoang

Communicating Risk Tolerance

Risk tolerance fluctuates; making a concerted effort to understand and communicate this with your partner before choosing an objective is crucial. It’s not a math equation, and factors may fluctuate, but the best question people can ask about risk tolerance is: “Are we generally on the same page?” Every major decision should come back to this once out in the mountains.

Acknowledging the Uncertainty

When out in the mountains, identify which hazards are high in uncertainty, and which are not. Can uncertainty about the potential outcomes be reduced? For some hazards like seracs, hanging ice daggers, or deeply buried avalanche problems we can’t reduce the uncertainty beyond conventional wisdom, it is what it is; for others we can. For example, if someone is contemplating a snow bridge to cross on a glacier, they can potentially reduce uncertainty by obtaining information: probing to find the edge of the bridge and determining its width and thickness. Uncertainty about snow bridges can’t be brought to zero, but the point is that if the information is easy to get, then get it. From there, consider the risk, ways to manage it, and whether an option seems reasonable to the group’s risk tolerance. The risk starts once they step onto the bridge. For experienced people, this decision process doesn’t take a long time. Practicing this process is worth it; acknowledging the uncertainty up front gives the most realistic picture of what the risk may be.

MountainLifeRockies v2 copy
Steve Holeczi and his client cross quickly under a serac on the south face of Mount Robson.
Photo: GRANT STATHAM, ILLUSTRATION BY JESSA GILBERT

Reflecting on Decisions

To learn from decisions made in highly-uncertain environments, the process that led to the decision is more important than the outcome; this concept is called decision quality. When the answer isn’t clear, people often rely on whether a positive or negative outcome occurred to determine whether good decisions were made. Although outcomes do matter, this way of thinking isn’t a reliable metric in these situations, because we can control the quality of the decision process, but when we act on them we don’t control the outcomes.

For example, a group decided on a waterfall ice climb. They were generally on the same page about their risk tolerance and acknowledged the higher uncertainty of hanging ice daggers above the route and possible outcomes. They discussed the risk, the ways to manage it (belaying in a cave, taking a climbing line as far away as possible from falling ice), and decided it was reasonable to take the chance. If one of the daggers fell off during the climb and injured or killed someone, people may assume they made poor choices. If the process was reasonable, then it wasn’t a bad decision. That’s the reality of uncertain environments.


You might also like:

Risking It All: Are the Mountains Worth Dying For?

In an alternate scenario, a group went to the same ice climb but didn’t discuss their risk tolerance for the day. One member of the group didn’t know much about hanging ice daggers, and there was no discussion about the daggers or possible outcomes. There was also no discussion about how to manage the risk. The group may get to the top of the climb without incident, but it doesn’t mean they made good choices. The process to get to the decision was poor.

The mountains are full of uncertainty, and many decisions are mainly based on subjective information and the psychology of the people making them. Ultimately, taking risks in the mountains requires some luck over time to come out unscathed, but acknowledging uncertainty and making higher-quality decisions can reduce the frequency that hope is used as a strategy.

ML

Check the ML Podcast!

ML-podcast-cover
Total
0
Shares
Share 0
Tweet 0
Pin it 0
Share 0
Share 0
Share 0
Related Topics
  • Rockies
  • Rocky Mountains
Mountain Life Media

Previous Article
The-High-Route-Kaytlyn-Gerbin-Jenny-Abegg-North-Cascades-High-Route-glacier-hiking
  • On The Trail
  • Trips & Expeditions
  • Videos

Friday Flick: Alpine Ultra-Run Sufferfest

  • March 10, 2023
  • Ned Morgan
View Post
Next Article
Bora-Boreal-Quebec-winter-cabin-stars
  • Mountain Lifer
  • Stay & Play

Bora Boréal: Frozen in Time and Ice

  • March 14, 2023
  • Mountain Life Media
View Post
You May Also Like
Leslie-Timms-Devils-Glen-Nutcracker-Colin-Field
View Post
  • CLIMBING
  • Ontario

Behind the Devil’s Glen Climbing Route Closures

  • Mountain Life Media
  • May 25, 2023
Paul-Manning-Hunter-Kananaskis-River-surf
View Post
  • In This Issue
  • Photography
  • Rockies

Mountain Life Takes Home Multiple Awards

  • Mountain Life Media
  • May 23, 2023
Lani-Imre-Jon-Turk
View Post
  • CLIMBING
  • Trips & Expeditions

Chased by Demons

  • Mountain Life Media
  • May 11, 2023
Miya-Tsudome-Patagonia-ascend-climbing-film-Yosemite
View Post
  • CLIMBING
  • Videos
  • Women

Fleeing the Taliban, Afghan Women Find a Home in Climbing

  • Editor
  • April 14, 2023
Sean-Mccoll-MEC-climbing-gym
View Post
  • CLIMBING

Climber Sean McColl Joins MEC as Latest Ambassador

  • Editor
  • April 13, 2023
Powder-Highway-BC-ski
View Post
  • Rockies
  • Skiing
  • Snowboarding

Powder Highway Revisited

  • Mountain Life Media
  • March 21, 2023
Brian-Hockenstein-surfing-Iceland-water-and-ice-ML
View Post
  • CLIMBING
  • Surfing
  • Trips & Expeditions

In the Land of Water & Ice

  • Editor
  • January 24, 2023
Marie-Pier-Desharnais-A-Womans-Experience-on-K2-flag-crop
View Post
  • CLIMBING

Marie-Pier Desharnais: A Woman’s Experience on K2

  • Mountain Life Media
  • January 23, 2023
Featured Posts
  • Kathryn-Corbiere-artist-Indigenous-Ontario-Blue-Mountains 1
    Artist Profile: Elevating Awareness 
    • May 29, 2023
  • Mike-Traslin-Andy-Traslin-ski-touring-KootenaysBC 2
    The Traslin Brothers: 200 Months of Earned Turns
    • May 30, 2023
  • Leslie-Timms-Devils-Glen-Nutcracker-Colin-Field 3
    Behind the Devil’s Glen Climbing Route Closures
    • May 25, 2023
  • Fisher-Monahan-illustration-illustrator 4
    Sweetgrass Chronicles: Walking from BC to San Francisco
    • May 26, 2023
  • Paul-Manning-Hunter-Kananaskis-River-surf 5
    Mountain Life Takes Home Multiple Awards
    • May 23, 2023
RECENT POSTS
  • John-Haines-Simcoe-Street-Collingwood2-at-CreativeSimcoe-Street
    Tribute: ML’s Map Artist John Haines
    • June 1, 2023
  • benno_bikes-46er-sea-otter-tour-web2
    Gear Shed: Picks for Spring & Summer
    • May 24, 2023
  • Baptism By Gravel: Rab Equipment Enters The Adventure Cycling Game
    • May 19, 2023
Social Links
Instagram 22K Followers
Facebook 0 Likes
Twitter 0 Followers
Pinterest 1K Followers
Vimeo 34 Followers
LinkedIn 0
INSTAGRAM

Warning: preg_match(): Unknown modifier '0' in /home/customer/www/mountainlifemedia.ca/public_html/wp-content/plugins/powerkit/modules/lazyload/helpers/helper-powerkit-lazyload.php on line 146
avatar
mountainlifemedia
Mountain Life
25K Followers
Just your average day on the trails…nothing to see here. #mountainlifer #onewheel 23 4
How many turns did you earn last winter? Most skiers and boarders would be proud to say they logged a week with no chairlifts and zero auxiliary help to the top—or toured exclusively for a month. 43 2
onekwe didn’t set out to become an artist. She first became a welder with the intention of establishing herself in the trade. But, as good welding jobs are few and far between where she lives on Manitoulin Island, she began doing commissions for architectural pieces and modern furniture. “From there, I found the opportunities and the abilities in myself to create art,” she says. 74 1
ML and partners offer a gear list curated for spring-summer stoke, including the latest sunnies, trail shoes, sun shirts, e-bikes, headlamps, racerback tanks, Rollerblades and sun hats. In alpha order. #linkinbio to check out all picks! 21 0
"Alright—where to begin? Between the months of July and November 2022, I walked about 2500 kilometres from British Columbia to San Francisco. Yes—I walked." 46 4
🚫The sweet sound of the wilderness at Devil’s Glen… 76 5
✨It's time for another giveaway! 66 124
☝️Ahem, so … we’re officially “award-winning” again. Yup: ML Rocky Mountains and ML Coast Mountains both received awards recently at the 2023 Alberta Magazine Publishers Association Conference. 80 9
We hope your long weekend was filled with adventure! Now sit back and relax while you enjoy episode 28 of Live It Up with Mountain Life featuring scottparentphoto! You’ve earned it 😉 #linkinbio 42 3
When you live in #Whistlerbc it’s that easy to change with the seasons 🌞 #mountainlifer 124 4
Follow

Subscribe

Subscribe now to our newsletter

Just your average day on the trails…nothing to see here. #mountainlifer #onewheel 23 4
How many turns did you earn last winter? Most skiers and boarders would be proud to say they logged a week with no chairlifts and zero auxiliary help to the top—or toured exclusively for a month. 43 2
onekwe didn’t set out to become an artist. She first became a welder with the intention of establishing herself in the trade. But, as good welding jobs are few and far between where she lives on Manitoulin Island, she began doing commissions for architectural pieces and modern furniture. “From there, I found the opportunities and the abilities in myself to create art,” she says. 74 1
ML and partners offer a gear list curated for spring-summer stoke, including the latest sunnies, trail shoes, sun shirts, e-bikes, headlamps, racerback tanks, Rollerblades and sun hats. In alpha order. #linkinbio to check out all picks! 21 0
"Alright—where to begin? Between the months of July and November 2022, I walked about 2500 kilometres from British Columbia to San Francisco. Yes—I walked." 46 4
🚫The sweet sound of the wilderness at Devil’s Glen… 76 5
Mountain Life
  • Home
  • About
  • Contact
  • Subscribe
  • Advertising

Input your search keywords and press Enter.